Tel: +86-18025912990 | Email: wst01@winsharethermal.com
Blog
English
Views: 2 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2025-10-21 Origin: Site
The demand for high-power thermal management is escalating rapidly across numerous demanding sectors.From next-generation AI servers and new energy IGBT modules to EV battery packs, these critical applications require liquid cold plates that offer not only high performance but also uncompromising reliability.
The overall performance of a liquid cold plate hinges on several intertwined factors. While material choice (like Copper or Aluminum) is fundamental, the joining process used to seal the cooling channels is absolutely critical. This process ensures the mechanical integrity of the cold plate, its leak-proof operation, and minimal thermal resistance from the baseplate to the coolant.
At Winshare Thermal, two dominant manufacturing techniques underpin our production of high-efficiency cold plates: Friction Stir Welding (FSW) and Vacuum Brazing. Both methods yield strong, sealed bonds, but they operate on completely different physical principles, leading to distinct advantages and limitations in product application.
This article will provide a clear, in-depth comparison of FSW and Vacuum Brazing from Winshare Thermal's manufacturing perspective. We will focus on four main areas: thermal performance, structural strength, manufacturing cost, and material applicability. This guide is designed to empower engineers to make the most informed process selection for their specific thermal management challenges.
Winshare Thermal's Commitment:
We hold deep expertise in both FSW and Vacuum Brazing technologies.Our state-of-the-art facilities and experienced engineering teams enable us to offer customized processing options. This ensures we deliver the optimal thermal solution for every client's specific needs – we don't just choose one method; we strategically apply the best method for the job, integrating seamlessly into your supply chain.
Friction Stir Welding (FSW) is a cornerstone technique in Winshare Thermal's manufacturing portfolio, particularly for robust Aluminum cold plates. It is a solid-state joining process, meaning the material never reaches its melting temperature.This fundamental difference endows FSW with unique structural benefits that are critical for high-reliability components.
Our FSW process leverages precisely controlled friction and mechanical force to achieve an exceptionally strong bond without melting the base metal.
Solid-State Joining Principle:
At Winshare Thermal, we use a non-consumable tool, precisely designed with a pin and a shoulder, which rotates at high speed. This tool is plunged into the seam between two precisely prepared workpieces. Frictional heat is generated, causing the material to become soft and plastic – but not molten.6 As the pin traverses the joint line, it mechanically stirs and mixes the plasticized material from both sides.7 Upon cooling, this stirring action forms a high-strength metallurgical bond with a refined grain structure.
Key Technical Strengths of Winshare Thermal's FSW:
| Technical Feature | Description | Winshare Thermal's Cold Plate Benefit |
| Solid-State Process | Joining occurs below the melting point, in our controlled CNC environment. | Eliminates common fusion welding defects like gas porosity and shrinkage, ensuring leak-free performance. |
| Minimal Heat-Affected Zone (HAZ) | Heat input is localized and precisely controlled. | Material properties of the base metal are largely preserved; minimal warping and distortion, ensuring high flatness. |
| Fine Grain Structure | Mechanical stirring refines the grain structure in the weld area. | Weld strength often exceeds 90% of the base material's strength, crucial for structural integrity. |
| No Consumables | No need for filler metal, flux, or shielding gas. | Reduced material cost, improved environmental friendliness, and a clean internal channel surface. |
This solid-state process is highly advantageous in our facility, as it intrinsically avoids the problems associated with traditional fusion welding, such as solidification cracking and gas porosity, delivering superior joint quality.
The inherent properties of Winshare Thermal's FSW process make it ideal for producing high-reliability cold plate components that withstand the harshest conditions.
Exceptional Structural Integrity and Pressure Resistance:
The weld seam created by our FSW process is fully dense and highly impervious to leaks.Winshare Thermal's FSW cold plates are 100% leak-free, a claim we validate through rigorous testing.These cold plates can consistently withstand very high pressures, up to 300 bar in some configurations.This unparalleled high-pressure resistance is crucial for aerospace, military, and high-flow industrial cooling systems where safety and performance cannot be compromised.
Low Distortion and High Repeatability:
Our precise control over localized heat input in FSW results in minimal thermal distortion. This allows our engineers to easily maintain a high degree of flatness for the cold plate's mounting surface – a critical factor for ensuring low thermal resistance at the contact interface with the heat source. Since the process is CNC controlled, we guarantee high dimensional accuracy and consistency across large production batches, meeting the stringent demands of mass production.
Ideal for Aluminum Alloys:
Winshare Thermal's FSW capabilities excel with various Aluminum alloys, including 1xxx, 5xxx, and 6xxx series. Aluminum is a preferred material for cold plates due to its light weight and cost-effectiveness.The FSW process also uniquely enables the joining of aluminum alloys that are considered unweldable by traditional fusion methods, expanding design possibilities.
Winshare Thermal's Practice:
We strategically leverage FSW for large-format, custom-shaped cold plates, which are common in EV battery packs and ESS systems. The exceptional structural strength ensures these cold plates survive high-vibration automotive environments, while the process provides high efficiency for sealing large, complex channels in aluminum components.
Vacuum Brazing is another core, well-established joining technology within Winshare Thermal's capabilities. It utilizes a liquid filler metal in a precisely controlled vacuum environment, offering unparalleled flexibility in design, particularly for highly complex internal structures that demand superior thermal performance.
Vacuum Brazing, as employed by Winshare Thermal, is a form of liquid-state joining where the base material does not melt during the process.
Liquid-State Joining Principle:
Components are meticulously assembled with a filler metal, chosen for its lower melting point than the base materials. The assembly is then placed inside one of our advanced vacuum furnaces. The furnace temperature is carefully ramped up, melting the filler material while keeping the base metals solid. Due to capillary action, the molten filler flows precisely into the tiny gaps between the components. The filler wets the base material surface and diffuses with the base metal, forming a strong, continuous metallurgical bond. The crucial vacuum environment prevents oxidation, which is critical for materials like Aluminum and Copper.
Key Technical Strengths of Winshare Thermal's Vacuum Brazing:
| Technical Feature | Description | Winshare Thermal's Cold Plate Benefit |
| Full Surface Bonding | Brazing filler flows over all contact surfaces, creating a complete bond. | Minimal interface thermal resistance; maximizes heat transfer efficiency for critical applications. |
| Contamination-Free | Process occurs in a high vacuum without flux. | Internal cooling channels remain extremely clean and corrosion-resistant, ensuring long-term reliability. |
| Complex Assembly | Multiple joints can be brazed simultaneously in one cycle. | Allows for highly complex, multi-component, or multi-layer cold plate designs (e.g., micro-channels, corrugated fins). |
| Material Versatility | Suitable for Copper, Aluminum, and sometimes joining dissimilar metals. | Offers maximum flexibility in material choice based on specific thermal needs and cost. |
Vacuum Brazing is the preferred method at Winshare Thermal when thermal performance is the absolute, uncompromising priority, enabling us to engineer solutions for the most demanding heat flux applications.
Superior Thermal Performance via Full Metallurgical Bonding:
Our Vacuum Brazing process achieves a seamless, metal-to-metal bond across the entire contact surface. This is a crucial distinction, as it inherently minimizes the interface thermal resistance between the base plate and the intricate internal cooling features. This superior bonding is why Winshare Thermal's brazed cold plates are selected for the highest heat flux applications, guaranteeing maximum heat is efficiently transferred to the coolant fluid.
Flexibility for Complex Internal Flow Paths:
Vacuum Brazing offers the highest degree of design freedom. This empowers our engineers to create highly complex internal structures, including integrated corrugated fins or intricate micro-channel structures. These features significantly increase the heat transfer surface area, maximizing convective heat transfer within the cold plate. The brazing filler metal precisely flows around and bonds these delicate internal features, sealing the entire assembly simultaneously.
Ideal for Micro-Channel and High-Density Designs:
Vacuum Brazing is the ideal process for manufacturing micro-channel cold plates and for bonding high-density Copper Skived Fin structures to a base plate. These advanced designs are absolutely necessary for cooling high-power CPU and GPU modules, which often have extremely high Thermal Design Power (TDP) ratings.
Winshare Thermal's Practice:
We routinely utilize vacuum brazing for CPU/GPU Copper cold plates and for IGBT cooling bases that demand complex internal geometries.25 This process ensures high reliability for components operating at the very edge of thermal limits, a testament to our precision manufacturing.
Choosing between Winshare Thermal's FSW and Vacuum Brazing capabilities involves a strategic balancing act of structural integrity, cost-effectiveness, and thermal performance requirements. There is no universally superior method; rather, it’s about applying the right tool for the right job.
Cost and production speed are often decisive factors in high-volume industries, where Winshare Thermal excels in both processes.
Winshare Thermal Investment and Operating Costs:
| Parameter | Friction Stir Welding (FSW) | Vacuum Brazing | Winshare Thermal Conclusion |
| Equipment Cost | Relatively Low (Our CNC machines with FSW head attachments) | Extremely High (Our large vacuum furnaces are significant investments, often >ϵ1 Million) | FSW Wins on initial investment cost. |
| Cycle Time | Fast (Linear welding speed 0.5-1.5 m/min) | Slow (Long furnace cycles, typically 6-10 hours per batch) | FSW Wins on speed and lead time for individual parts. |
| Consumables | None (Non-consumable tool) | High (Brazing filler metal, inert gas for cooling) | FSW Wins on operating costs per part. |
Cost Conclusion: FSW is generally 2 to 10 times more cost-effective than brazing for small to medium batch sizes due to lower initial investment and faster production. However, Winshare Thermal's Vacuum Brazing facilities achieve significant economies of scale in very large, standardized production runs, as multiple parts can be stacked and processed simultaneously in one furnace cycle, making the per-part cost highly competitive.
The fundamental difference in principle between FSW and Vacuum Brazing leads to distinct performance and reliability trade-offs, which Winshare Thermal engineers carefully evaluate.
Winshare Thermal Performance and Reliability Trade-Offs:
| Factor | Friction Stir Welding (FSW) | Vacuum Brazing | Winshare Thermal's Application Focus |
| Interface Thermal Resistance | Very Good (Metallurgical bond at the seam) | Excellent (Full surface metallurgical bond) | Brazing for peak TDP components and micro-channels. |
| Structural Integrity (Leak/Pressure) | Highest (100% leak-free, up to 300 bar) | High (Reliable, but risk of porosity/brazing failure in overly complex joints) | FSW for high-vibration, high-pressure systems like EV battery packs. |
| Post-Weld Hardness | No significant drop (Low HAZ) | Significant drop (Requires re-heat treatment, which adds cost and complexity) | FSW is better for maintaining material integrity without post-processing. |
| Design Flexibility | Lower (Limited by tool access and linear weld paths) | Highest (Allows for intricate fins, micro-channels, and complex internal baffling) | Brazing for custom thermal optimization and maximum surface area. |
Engineering Decision at Winshare Thermal: If the application is structurally demanding – requiring high vibration and high-pressure resistance (e.g., EV automotive, aerospace) – FSW offers the best structural assurance. If the application demands extreme heat flux and complex internal micro-channels where thermal efficiency is prioritized above all else (e.g., AI processors, IGBTs), Vacuum Brazing is the superior choice.
The manufacturing decision between FSW and Vacuum Brazing is not about identifying a universally superior technology. Instead, it is about Winshare Thermal's expertise in choosing the optimal technology tailored to the specific product constraints and performance objectives.
FSW provides a clear advantage when structural strength, high reliability in harsh environments, and cost-efficient production of large aluminum parts are the top priorities. It is our gold standard process for EV battery cooling plates.
Vacuum Brazing is the essential process for maximizing thermal performance. It excels in micro-channel design, complex multi-component assembly, and situations where the absolute lowest interface thermal resistance is required. It is our process of choice for high-end CPU and GPU cold plates.
At Winshare Thermal, we empower engineers to make this critical decision based on four core criteria:
Thermal Flux Density: (High density to Brazing for superior interface bond)
Working Pressure/Vibration: (High stress to FSW for monolithic structural integrity)
Annual Production Volume: (High, standardized to Brazing for batch efficiency; Medium/Custom to FSW for tooling flexibility)
Material Required: (Aluminum large plates to FSW; Copper/Hybrid/Complex Fins to Brazing)
Do not leave your process decision to chance. Consult with Winshare Thermal's experienced team. We leverage our advanced design, simulation, and DFM (Design for Manufacturability) capabilities to ensure the most suitable cold plate manufacturing process is selected for your project. This guarantees the highest performance and reliability for your IGBT, ESS, or AI system, backed by our TS16949 certification and proven expertise.
