Tel: +86-18025912990 | Email: wst01@winsharethermal.com
Blog
English
Views: 11 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2025-10-21 Origin: Site
At Winshare Thermal, we witness firsthand the escalating demand for high-performance cooling across critical sectors like Electric Vehicles (EVs), Energy Storage Systems (ESS), and high-density computing for AI servers. In these applications, effectively managing heat is not just a design challenge – it's a make-or-break factor for system reliability and longevity.
The liquid cold plate stands as the indispensable thermal interface, directly transferring heat from components like IGBT modules or power battery cells to the cooling fluid.The foundational choice of material for this cold plate profoundly impacts its cooling effectiveness, structural integrity, and overall cost-effectiveness.3
Engineers invariably face the decision between Copper (Cu) and Aluminum (Al). At Winshare Thermal, our philosophy is not to declare one material universally superior, but to pinpoint the optimal material and manufacturing process precisely suited for each specific application's unique thermal, mechanical, and budgetary requirements.
Winshare Thermal's Commitment:
With extensive manufacturing capabilities encompassing Vacuum Brazing, Friction Stir Welding (FSW), and our specialized Tubed (embedded tube) cold plate designs, we excel in working with both Copper and Aluminum. This versatility, combined with our deep engineering expertise, allows us to provide clients with unbiased, solution-focused material and process recommendations, ensuring the highest performance and reliability for their critical thermal management needs.
Our selection of the right material for a cold plate begins with a rigorous comparison of core physical properties. At Winshare Thermal, we meticulously evaluate these metrics to ensure the manufactured cold plate delivers on performance and feasibility.
Thermal conductivity (k) is the paramount factor, dictating a material's inherent ability to conduct heat.
| Material | Thermal Conductivity (W/m⋅K) | Relative Performance | Winshare Thermal's Manufacturing Approach |
| Copper ()Cu | ~ 400 | Excellent (Highest) | Favored for Vacuum Brazing and Skived Fin cold plates in high-flux applications. |
| Aluminum ()Al | ~ 205 | Good | Ideal for FSW and Brazed aluminum plates in weight-sensitive, distributed heat scenarios. |
Copper's superior thermal conductivity (~ 205 W/m⋅K)) makes it the clear leader for maximizing heat transfer efficiency.This is critically important for applications with extremely high heat flux, where concentrated heat from power electronics like high-frequency IGBTs demands the lowest possible junction temperature (T_j) and stringent thermal resistance budgets.
Aluminum, while having a lower k value, still offers good conductivity and is highly effective for applications where the heat load is more distributed.
Winshare Thermal's Manufacturing Edge:
We leverage our expertise in Vacuum Brazing Copper to create cold plates for the most demanding high-flux applications (e.g., CPU/GPU cooling), where the full potential of Copper's conductivity is realized through superior metallurgical bonding.
System weight is a significant design consideration, particularly in mobile and large-scale transportation applications.
| Material | Density ()g/cm3 | Weight Ratio | Winshare Thermal's Application Focus |
| Copper ()Cu | 8.96 | ~3.3 ╳Al | Used when extreme thermal performance outweighs weight concerns. |
| Aluminum ()Al | 2.70 | 1 ╳ | The preferred material for large-scale, weight-sensitive designs using FSW and brazing. |
Copper's high density () makes it nearly three times heavier than Aluminum () by volume. This substantial weight difference is paramount in large systems like cabinets or large battery packs. Utilizing Aluminum cold plates, often fabricated via our ~8.96 g/cm^3~2.70 g/cm^3 ESSEV FSW process, results in significant cumulative weight savings, directly impacting vehicle range, system integration, and shipping logistics.
Winshare Thermal's Manufacturing Edge:
Our advanced Friction Stir Welding (FSW) capabilities are specifically optimized for Aluminum alloys, allowing us to produce large, lightweight, and structurally robust cold plates that are essential for the cumulative weight savings required in EV and ESS applications.
The final material selection at Winshare Thermal extends beyond just thermal properties. Our engineering considerations encompass practical manufacturing issues, cost optimization, and crucial long-term fluid compatibility to ensure maximum reliability.
Cost is frequently a dominant factor, especially in mass-market applications.
Aluminum generally presents a lower raw material cost, directly impacting the system's material budget.Crucially, aluminum is also highly amenable to various manufacturing processes, allowing for faster production cycles – a key advantage for mass-produced components.
Winshare Thermal's Manufacturing Edge:We extensively employ Friction Stir Welding (FSW) for our Aluminum cold plates. FSW is an outstanding solid-state joining process that creates high-integrity bonds with complex internal fin geometries, making it exceptionally cost-effective and efficient for high-volume aluminum cold plate production.
Copper, while offering superior performance, is more expensive in terms of raw material and can be slower to machine. However, in certain scenarios, a smaller, less complex Copper plate (e.g., a Vacuum Brazed Copper cold plate) can outperform a larger, more complex Aluminum plate, potentially offsetting its higher initial material and processing costs.
Corrosion is a critical long-term reliability risk in any liquid cooling system. Galvanic corrosion, occurring when dissimilar metals contact an electrolyte (the cooling fluid), is a significant concern in mixed-metal loops (e.g., an Aluminum cold plate connected to a Copper heat exchanger).
| System Configuration (Winshare Thermal Solutions) | Corrosion Risk | Solution and Requirement |
| All-Copper Loop | Low | Excellent long-term reliability. Our Vacuum Brazed Copper plates are ideal. |
| All-Aluminum Loop | Moderate | Requires specific, inhibited coolants (e.g., glycol). Our FSW Aluminum plates excel here. |
| Mixed Loop ()Cu/Al | High | Requires robust passivation/plating (e.g., Nickel plating on Cu components) and very strict coolant controls. We offer expert guidance for such complex systems. |
An all-Copper system generally provides the best long-term reliability against corrosion. An all-Aluminum system, often fabricated via our FSW process, eliminates galvanic issues but still requires specific, inhibited coolants to prevent basic aluminum corrosion.
A mixed Cu/Al system, while offering design flexibility, poses the highest risk and demands meticulous engineering. This includes careful material selection, robust component plating (such as Nickel plating on our Copper components), and specialized corrosion inhibitors in the fluid – all areas where Winshare Thermal provides expert consultation and manufacturing capabilities. Ignoring these factors can lead to premature system failure and costly downtime.
The choice between Copper and Aluminum is profoundly influenced by the specific application's thermal profile and operational constraints. At Winshare Thermal, we provide tailored recommendations based on our extensive experience across key industries.
This category encompasses systems with high, concentrated heat loads, such as IGBT modules, power conversion units, and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs).
Winshare Thermal Recommendation: Copper
Reasoning: These applications demand the absolute lowest possible thermal resistance to manage high-density heat bursts and keep sensitive semiconductor junctions cool. Copper's superior conductivity, maximized through our Vacuum Brazing and Skived Fin processes, is non-negotiable for reliability and operational efficiency.
Example: Cooling solutions for high-power Wind Power Converters and AI server processors.
This involves cooling large battery packs and modules where the heat load is typically distributed across many cells.
Winshare Thermal Recommendation: Aluminum
Reasoning: These applications prioritize low weight, large size, and cost-efficiency. While the heat load is distributed, Aluminum, especially when processed with our FSW technology, provides sufficient thermal performance. Its low density and favorable cost make it ideal for the massive scale required. Our FSW Aluminum cold plates are structurally robust and highly cost-effective for large-format integrations like Power Battery Packs.
Example: Cooling plates for $\text{EV}$ battery modules and large-scale ESS cabinets.
This category includes cooling high-power processors,GPUs, and AI accelerators in high-density rack environments.
Winshare Thermal Recommendation: Copper (Interface) or Hybrid
Reasoning: Server components require extreme performance in a limited space. We often utilize Copper baseplates (e.g., Vacuum Brazed) that directly contact the CPU or GPU to maximize heat extraction from the smallest area. For larger components of the cooling loop, like manifolds or rack heat exchangers, Aluminum may be used to save weight and cost. This hybrid approach, supported by our multi-process manufacturing capabilities, offers maximum thermal performance at the most critical point. We provide expert guidance on fluid chemistry to mitigate mixed-metal corrosion risks in such complex hybrid systems.
Example: Direct-to-chip cold plates for AI servers and liquid-cooled CDU components.
The choice between Copper and Aluminum cold plates is a fundamental engineering trade-off. It’s a decision that Winshare Thermal helps you navigate with precision and expertise.
Choose Copper when maximum thermal performance and long-term corrosion reliability in a pure-metal system (often achieved through our Vacuum Brazing or Skived Fin processes) are the paramount concerns for high-flux components.
Choose Aluminum when weight savings, cost efficiency, and scalability for large, distributed heat loads (typically manufactured using our FSW or Aluminum Brazing capabilities) are the primary drivers.
The "better" choice is unequivocally the one that achieves the optimal balance, meeting specific thermal requirements, system budgets, and all mechanical and chemical constraints. Relying on estimates is insufficient. Winshare Thermal provides an advanced design and analysis team, comprised of elites from the industry's top global thermal companies. We offer dedicated engineering support, conduct comprehensive thermal and mechanical simulations, and perform Design for Manufacturability (DFM) analysis across our diverse range of manufacturing processes.
This integrated approach ensures that the absolute right material and manufacturing process are selected for your project, guaranteeing the highest performance, reliability, and cost-effectiveness for your critical applications.
